YORK REGION MOBILITY PLUS LEAVES ME MINUS MOBILITY

In early January, I moved from Toronto to Newmarket. I have severe Muscular Dystrophy and use an electric wheelchair. It took a lot of planning to ensure that I would be able to function in my new home and community.

I applied to Mobility Plus, York Region’s specialized transportation service, in December. Shortly after I moved, I was visited by an Inspector who needed to confirm that I am unable to use a minivan because of my height and chair size. I soon received my registration card and was on my way…or so I thought.

I booked a ride to go to a medical appointment and when the bus arrived, I boarded. My attendant took up her usual position beside me. The nature of my disability requires that I have neck and head support as well as assistance balancing to facilitate my breathing. I was shocked when the driver of the vehicle said my attendant had to sit and wear a seatbelt at all times. After explaining my needs to her, the driver made a phone call and said she couldn’t proceed unless the attendant sat down. Even if my attendant was sitting a couple of feet from me, the driver stated she couldn’t undo her belt to assist me. It’s interesting to note that on the Mobility Plus application, one of the questions asks if the applicant requires an attendant to travel with them, and why. If the accompanying attendant cannot assist the applicant, why would they require an attendant? It boggles the mind. I had no choice but to disembark and miss my appointment.

I immediately contacted the Inspector who had met with me and was told to provide a physician’s letter explaining why the attendant needed to stand. I submitted a letter, was given an amendment by their office, and sent in the revised note. After hearing nothing for 10 days, I contacted the Inspector again. Over the last few weeks, I’ve been given a myriad of reasons why I cannot be accommodated and yes, I am still waiting for resolution. Late last week, the Inspector gave the impression that nothing could be done. On Friday, I received an e-mail from someone in authority who said they are “still investigating“.

Surely I am not the only consumer who requires assistance while on a vehicle? People stand on “regular” busses every day. I can’t help but wonder how many people who do not know how to self-advocate (or have the support of family and friends) are sitting housebound after being told the same thing.

Ironically, I sent my resume to the York Region Accessibility Advisory Committee when I heard that they were looking for members to help make York Region more accessible for people with disabilities. I was delighted when they contacted me for an interview. Unfortunately, I was unable to schedule and attend a meeting with them and have missed a wonderful opportunity to contribute to my new community. I suggested that they consider using my current transportation predicament as a future agenda item.

I’m supposed to receive an update from Mobility Plus today or Tuesday, so watch this space.

Your Questions Answered

Just wanted to answer the questions posted. First, Wheel-Trans buses have grab bars.

Second, no, I don't have an attendant beside me 24/7, because when I am in a building or on the street, it is not moving and repeatedly turning corners at 30km/h. This is assistance that I require when in a vehicle. Without knowing me and the severity of my disability, it's understandable one might be "astounded" that a solution hasn't been found. Anyone with a progressive disability has learned (or will) that affects are individual and unpredictable. Isn't that why we're fighting to be accommodated instead of accepting society's cookie-cutter attitude?

The inquirys done re this

The inquirys done re this matter to the TTC and their practise have rattled the chains of the higher ups and legal...Rumour has it that the whole issue of standing in a TTC vehicle with seatbelts will be looked at from a legal and liability standpoint. There may be changes coming to the TTC that are in line with the other transit systems in the province.

As a YRAAC member, we'd welcome any deputation or communication, we'd comment and question and pass it off to the manager of Mobility Plus. She would present her position, and we'd either agree or disagree, but we cannot change the Highway Traffic Act, nor the very real concern of liability that both Mobility and the Region have...thus the term 'Advisory'.

I must also give a tip of my hat to Mobility Plus...we have worked closely with them and they have responded to our concerns in a timely and productive manner, and if the answer is not one we agree with, they have explained if and why something can't be changed. I cannot think of one instance in the past 4 years where we have disagreed with Transit's position after it was explained.

Finally, I am astounded that there are no OT or PT device solutions to your issue. Do you have an attendant stand beside you 24/7? There has got to be a better way. (ha ha...thats the TTC slogan, the better way;)

Unbelievable!

Who would have thought that Toronto would ever be more flexible than a smaller, friendlier community? On Wheel-Trans, "non-registered riders" are permitted to stand in the vehicle, just as they are permitted to stand on a conventional city bus. Please keep us posted!